William Justice returned to the United States after nearly four years traveling the world and working with winemakers. He had sold his Manhattan restaurant, planned to open a winery, and wasn't sure he would stay in the country.
Then he came to Portland.
Justice was eating oysters across the street from 122 Washington Avenue when a FOR RENT sign appeared. He liked the location and the bones of the space. He called almost immediately.
Sweetfern Geometer followed.
Justice grew up in rural Kansas and studied Russian literature with plans to become a writer. He later moved to Berkeley and worked for a small independent publisher, where his interest in local agriculture led to an unexpected career in catering. Food eventually took over. He opened a restaurant in his Kansas hometown, followed by a bookstore and coffee shop, and later built a career as a chef and restaurateur in Manhattan.
At Sweetfern, the menu starts with what is available.
Justice works primarily with local farms for produce and grows tomatoes, cucumbers, herbs, edible flowers, and other ingredients in a Portland garden. Dishes change with the harvest.
“It was a straight line between what the farmer had, what I made, and what you ate,” he says of the approach he developed at his previous restaurant.
One recent dish paired purple-skinned carrots with fennel cream and fennel flowers. A limited supply of local cantaloupe became another, served with purple basil, green jalapeños, cardamom, and black volcanic salt. The point isn't complexity for its own sake. It's finding an ingredient at its best and giving it enough attention to stand on its own.
Diners can order from the menu or leave the decisions to Justice. His $45 chef's choice includes six courses and draws partly on meals he encountered while traveling through Turkey, Morocco, Greece, rural France, Japan, and the Republic of Georgia. In many of those places, he found a style of hospitality centered less on giving diners an abundance of choices and more on serving what was available in the moment.
Customers have described Sweetfern as feeling like eating in a chef's home. Justice likes that description. The food has experience and technique behind it, but he isn't interested in making it showy or pretentious. He wants dinner to feel welcoming, thoughtful, and connected to the place and season it's served in.
Even the restaurant's name tells part of the story.
Sweetfern is an edible plant native to Maine, and the sweetfern geometer is a local moth. Next door, Justice operates Mourning Cloak, a bakery and breakfast sandwich shop named for a native butterfly. The names connect the two businesses and reflect their ecological focus.
There is also a more personal reference tucked inside them. One of Justice's favorite writers, Vladimir Nabokov, was also a butterfly specialist. For Justice, who still intends to write seriously, the reference serves as a private reminder.
A restaurant, he says, can become “all-encompassing and immersive.” The moth reminds him to keep another part of himself alive.
122 Washington Ave, Portland, ME | Make a reservation on OpenTable
photos by Peter Logue